PHOTOS: RICHIE DOWNS | When it comes to Irish rock, I’ve always been a Pogues man. Their frenetic reels and rockers have always spoken to the madman in me, just as the great Shane MacGowan has always touched my drunkard’s heart. The time I saw them poor Shane was so totally paralytic he was reduced to clinging to the mike stand for dear life, like a sailor clutching a capstan in a savage squall to keep from plunging into the pitiless clutches of the great tossing sea. His voice was a wreck, as befits a man burning himself down with Bushmills and the Black Stuff (to say nothing of the white stuff), but even in his ruin MacGowan was still pure dead brilliant.
But I’ve since come to appreciate the greatness of another Irish band, The Waterboys. While their Celtic folk/rock lacks the whiplash tempos and demented energy of the Pogues, The Waterboys have their own calmer charms. At his best front man Mike Scott shares Van Morrison’s sage’s soul and as nigh to earth as Heaven brand of Celtic spirituality. And The Waterboys’ louder LPs, while less uniquely Irish and more traditional in the mode of U2, prove they aren’t nicknamed “The Big Music” for nothing. And any band that can produce a cover of “Sweet Thing” every bit as moving as Van the Man’s original has earned my undying love.
Formed in 1983, The Waterboys have run through an astounding number of members—I count 65 former W-Boys, a number that rivals Mark E. Smith’s serial-killer body count—with Scott being the only constant. They played a big noise in their early days, then took a turn to more folksy material, and have swung back and forth between “The Big Music” and folk ever since. They’ve broken up and reformed, and put out 10 studio LPs in all, but their masterpiece (in my inarguable critic’s opinion) is 1988’s folksier Fisherman’s Blues.